[Skip to Content]


Location Info

Our location map
611 W. Northland Avenue
Appleton, WI 54911
Look for stores with the Gold Standard Seal. They have been recognized for achieving the highest standards in Product, Quality, Operations and Customer Service.
This store accepts gift cards

Store Hours

Mon:09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Tues:09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Wed:09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Thu:09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Fri:09:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Sat:09:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Sun:11:00 AM - 05:00 PM

Contact Store


for News and Promotions

Your one stop shop for all your sporting needs!

At Play It Again Sports in Appleton we specialize in baseball, softball, fitness, lacrosse, disc golf, golf and much more. Our staff members are trained to make sure you are getting the right fit and equipment the first time. So stop down and let our staff help you get everything you need for the upcoming season.


We are located at 611 W. Northland Ave behind the Starbucks and PDQ carwash. You can reach us at 920-735-0432 or pias11429@gmail.com

Now Buying your gently used Sporting Goods!

At Play It Again Sports Appleton we are always buying your used sporting equipment! Check out our top ten items we are currently looking for below

Top Ten Items

1. Baseball/Softball Gloves, Cleats, Pants

2. Little League (USA Stamped), Senior League, High School, Fastpitch Bats

3.Soccer Shin Guards, Cleats, Balls, Nets

4. Proline Golf Equipment

5. Youth and Adult Bikes

6. Rollerblades and Skateboards

7. Metal/Rubber Dumbbells, Metal/Rubber Plates

8. Wrestling Shoes, Headgear

9. Hockey and Figure Skates

10. Lacrosse sticks, balls, protective gear

What's It Worth?

We are always looking to buy gently used gear.
Submit your gear and we will tell you what it is worth and if we can buy it.

Indoor Batting Cages $6 all you can hit
Baseball and Softball Available
Hide This Message